Has motherhood made me an easier mark?

baby rental

Dean has always said that I have a soft heart. I have compassion for people, I just can’t help it. Part of it is that I have empathy, that I can feel for other human beings and imagine how hard it must be in their situation. I also am a writer, and I know that it wouldn’t be hard to write the scenario where Dean and I fall on hard times. It’s a common story for so many people – economies struggle, jobs are shed, people get hurt, the list goes on and on. I know that Dean and I work hard for our life, and that even our comfortable existence could be turned on its head.

Since Harley came along, I’ve become even more sensitive. I mourn for strangers as someone’s baby. I feel for other mothers, no matter the struggles they experience, and I want to do anything I can to make life better for other people. However, I have noticed that my sensitivity and empathy might also be making me an easier mark for con artists.

Joburg is filled with desperate people. It’s sad and horrifying, but can’t be argued. There are beggars at pretty much every intersection, which is why I tend to roll my windows up when approaching them along my usual routes. I’ve gotten used to the usual beggars along the way – the blind guy with the kid, the fake disabled one with crutches (who I’ve seen run for a taxi after his “shift” ends), the guy with leprosy and without fingers. Growing up in New York, I know about homeless beggars and the sad reality of needing to look away, to not give everyone money. I do try and help where I can – giving my leftover food if I’m not going to eat it after a night at a restaurant, or donating clothes and other goods to my maid or other charity drives.

Lately, though, a woman appeared along my usual route. She carries a small baby. I know that most of these women are scammers. I know that there’s a huge racket here in Joburg where women can get paid hundreds of Rands to rent their babies out for a day, a week, a month. I can only imagine the level of desperation a woman must be experiencing to “rent” her baby to another woman, to a stranger. Even knowing that, I couldn’t help myself – I rolled my window down and gave the woman R10. I hoped that I was helping, but I also decided to ask a couple questions while waiting at the intersection – I asked her if it was a boy or a girl, how old he was.

Maybe it was a language barrier, but I think it was something more sinister. She said he was a boy, and was five months old. No way was that baby five months old. And the way she held him, looked at him… She thanked me for the money, but when I asked about the baby she didn’t look at him, didn’t smile, did pat him or show any affection. I was scammed. I played into the baby rental underbelly of this city, and it makes me so sad.

I’ve seen her since that day, never rolling down my window or offering money. But I still feel for that little baby, wonder about his future, wonder what chance at a good life he will have when his time as a baby is spent on street corners begging for money. Will he go to school when he’s the right age? Will he grow up to get a job? Or will he instead become some sort of crime lord, paying women a pittance to rent their babies to better beggars? Will the next young mom at the intersection give them money, continuing this awful cycle?

Motherhood has made me more empathetic, more understanding, more compassionate. But I wonder if it has also made me an easier mark. I avoided the guy in the shops who asked for help to buy nappies and formula – pointed him out to management, who escorted him off the premises as he’s a known conman. I don’t fall for plenty of scams, but I do see that I could become an easier mark. What if the next begging woman really is holding her precious baby? What if she is just trying to get enough money to buy something to eat, something to give her baby? Can I really just say no to anyone and everyone in need just in case they’re a scammer?


If you like these words, please check out more of what I say on twitter and Facebook, and pics I take on Instagram and subscribe to my YouTube channel. Also, please be sure to sign up to my carefully curated, crafted and infrequent newsletter.

  • Ursula Van Lelyveld

    My goodness, I hadn’t even heard of babies being rented out for this purpose

    • Zoe Hawkins

      yeah, there have been a few investigative reports about it. sad and scary stuff 🙁

  • I have always been an easy mark, I’ve fallen for the “we’ve run out of petrol” the “I need formula for my babies” the “we are destitute and just need bread and milk to eat” the “disabled beggar who runs for the money when you toot for him”.

    I cannot help everyone who needs it but I do what I can, I won’t ever give money anymore but whatever I do give, I give with a good heart. My intentions when I give are good, what they person receiving does with my good intention is on them. If they take my food and sell it for drink, that is on them. I gave them food hoping their belly would be full for one day.

    Good luck on this one, with so much need out there it is SO hard to know when it is “right” to give or not. Listen to your heart.


    • Zoe Hawkins

      yeah, also hard when Harley gets old enough to ask about things and hopefully also want to be generous. Considered keeping food in my car to give to beggars at intersections… just so hard to know the real people in need vs the scammers, and also don’t want to perpetuate the systemic poverty and begging-based problems either.

  • Easy mark, doesn’t even cover me. I once got reprimanded by someone I was helping for being too trusting. Like Sam mentioned, it’s not money anymore. It’s helped me get better at it.

    • Zoe Hawkins

      For sure – I like giving clothes, food and anything else, but when someone asks for money for nappies or formula, it pulls at my heart so much more now than it used to. i obviously have far too much empathy.

  • SoThisIsMotherhood

    Oh, I am totally a sucker. Great post by the way. I think motherhood definitely creates a softer spot within us. I try not to lose faith in humanity, it’s disturbing the levels people go to take advantage of others. I try to offer most a little bit of something, some kind of help, as I simply reach within to consider the best in everyone and hope I don’t screwed royally when its over.

    • Zoe Hawkins

      Thanks! Yeah, i think it’s hard to maintain faith in humanity when we keep seeing so many who are taken advantage of. But we have to keep trying, right?

  • I am also a sucker and have given money for the baby and bought the baby formula! Motherhood AND getting older are definitely making us soft targets!

    • Zoe Hawkins

      For sure! So much more empathy.

  • Pingback: New friends, old friends, fake friends - Born Geek()