Promiscuous feminists, rape culture, bathrooms and mothering a daughter

stanford rape case

I tried to write this post yesterday and failed miserably. Maybe it’s because I felt like there was a lack of focus to my post, or maybe because there were so many things I wanted to write about. It felt like a jumbled mess and I wasn’t sure how to share it. But then I realized that just because my thoughts are a jumbled mess doesn’t mean I shouldn’t share them. So, here’s what I’m thinking about at the moment, mostly inspired by the whole Stanford rape case situation.

It starts with location. I remember when I was getting ready to move to South Africa, I was very aware that Joburg was the rape capital of the world – not exactly an accolade for the city. I was worried that I would become a victim, that South Africa would feel more dangerous than any other place I’ve ever lived. Luckily, I still live a very safe life, but I am aware of the risks in this country. Then again, I’m no more aware here than I was growing up in New York City, or living in LA or any other city. It’s an awareness and vigilance that women worldwide need to have.

Then again, I’ve been thinking about Harley and emigrating. Part of the desire to move was tied to keeping her safe and giving her better opportunities. I was worried that I wouldn’t be able to keep her safe here in SA, and that when she was old enough to head off to university, that the state of education would be so deteriorated that it would sort of be impossible for her. Part of my fantasy of leaving South Africa involved moving to the San Francisco area where she could attend any California university she might want, including Stanford where she might be a legacy because my brother went there.

Yeah, that’s also a thing – my brother went to Stanford. So when I read about something happening on campus, it’s not a theoretical campus in my head. I’ve driven on those streets, been to those frat parties, met their star athletes. And in my fantasy of an awesome life in the US of A, Harley could escape the dangers of South Africa and attend Stanford to pursue her dreams. But even there dreams aren’t safe – rape happens anywhere. Everywhere.

And even if the worst were to happen, there’s no guarantee that justice would be served. Amidst all the debates about barring transgendered people from using the bathroom of their choice for fear of what they might do, the same places are actually unwilling to punish those individuals who actually do assault and rape. The same thing they’re worried that convicted rapist might face in prison is exactly what he did to his victim.

So where can Harley go and be safe? Is there anywhere? When I was in university, I was exactly the kind of promiscuous party animal that the prosecution in the Stanford case tried to paint the victim as. I used to go out partying. I’d get drunk. I’d have sex with people without being in a long term monogamous relationship. In a way, it was part of my approach to feminism. I was proud to embrace my sexuality, to own it, to do whatever felt right to me. But does that mean that I would have “deserved” to be raped? That I would have been asking for it? And not that this lady was like me, but promiscuous feminists can also be raped.

I remember being so careful of how I dressed growing up, so as not to entice strangers, not to set myself up for a sexual assault. I remember fighting with my mom as I went through puberty, not understanding that I’d need to be careful, that she was trying to protect me. I wonder if Harley and I will have those same fights – not because I want to hide her beauty, but because I’m so afraid of how strangers will look at her, feeling entitled to ogle her, touch her, assault her.

So where does that leave me today? I guess I’m just worried about my little girl. I hope that she can grow up in a safer world, one where she can attend university with her biggest worries being final exams or if the person she likes is also interested in her. I hope that she can follow her dreams without fear of assault and judgement. And I’m so very sad – that victim on the Stanford campus could be been me, could have been any of us. Rape is a global problem, and it can happen to our mothers, our sisters, our daughters, our girlfriends, our wives.


If you like these words, please check out more of what I say on twitter and Facebook, and pics I take on Instagram and subscribe to my YouTube channel. Also, please be sure to sign up to my carefully curated, crafted and infrequent newsletter.

  • konfab

    Just get her to do Engineering.
    No social life = no chance of participating in the party/rape thing.

    • Her Highness the Hipster

      Hah, if only it were that simple. 😛

  • Pingback: My first ever mommy blogger meet-up | discomombulated()

  • Naxie

    i continue to follow this horrible story and feel such sadness for the woman who was raped by this guy – and i am infuriated about his teeny sentence for such a monstrous crime. also – this is about any of us, at any age – who are female – how can we keep our daughters safe? the answer is – who the hell knows. you and i have discussed “close calls” that we’ve both had in our lives – those times of what i guess we might call “almost rapes” – i am writing this with tears in my eyes – i NEVER want you or Harley to be harmed in ANY way.

    in a perfect world, all women would be safe from sexual violence. instead, we have a world where one can dress like a nun – can BE a nun – can be by society’s standards, unattractive – and even that woman is at risk of being sexually violated. rape is never about sex – it’s about the very worst abuse of power.

    we can teach our girls to use their voices, encourage them to take self-defense classes, dress modestly when out and about in a big city – but really, i think we delude ourselves into believing by doing those things we know how to keep ourselves safe.

    maybe it comes down to luck – which i wish for you and the princess – and all of us. clearly, we need it.

    • Her Highness the Hipster

      YES! this. a million times this. It never is about sex, but about power and luck. so so sad, and so scary. I used to think the worst thing I could imagine is being raped, but now the worst thing I could imagine is anyone touching Harley. I wish I could just keep her safe in my arms (and sometimes her walking ring or cot) forever.

  • Pingback: Yup, I'm still myself - Born Geek()

  • Pingback: Why I'm a part of #CarseatFullstop - Born Geek()

  • Pingback: Equality is impossible so suck it up - Born Geek()